Drooling at the Prospects: Do the Jays Need to Replace Jose Bautista?

*EDITOR’S NOTE* Please welcome the newest contributor Wes Kepstro to the AL Eastbound team.  I’m excited to add such a dedicated Blue Jays (and baseball) fan and he brings a unique combination of advanced statistical analysis and a flair for writing.  Welcome aboard Wes!

In my previous article I extolled the virtues of the Jays RF, Jose Bautista, and talked a little bit about how his injury will effect the team.  But there are other angles to consider.  On this Jays squad he’s the best player, and with a farm that’s shallow in the upper levels he’s irreplaceable.  Or is he?  He’d achieved 3.2 fWAR by the time of his injury, so projecting a season total of 5.5 fWAR is reasonable.  He’d be costly, but not impossible to replace.  The Cardinals are in the race again, despite losing Albert Pujols and his 5.1 fWAR from last season.  Given his defensive shortcomings, his age, and his wrist injury, the Jays may need to replace him, but Jose Bautista is replaceable.

There are at least two problems facing the Jays and their fans if he doesn’t return at 100%.  First, the present-day Jays are what it looks like to have Jose on the DL.  They won one series in August, owing in large part to the fact that they couldn’t score runs.  On one hand this reflects well on the Jays.  Oftentimes, rebuilding teams drop like a stone in the standings: one needs only to look at the Houston Astros over the last couple of seasons for satisfactory evidence.  The Jays haven’t, and Jose Bautista has been a key reason why they haven’t.  He isn’t solely responsible for their relative success, of course, but he’s the best player on a mediocre team.  Hats off to Alex Anthopoulos and staff for recognizing his talent and signing him to a good deal for the next few years.  On the other hand it betrays a lack of depth.  If he doesn’t come back healthy, the Jays can expect a serious setback in the rebuilding process.

The second problem they face if he doesn’t return at full strength is replacing him with a player of similar value.  The Jays have incurred the wrath of some  fans by failing to acquire the pitching that everyone and their brother knows they need.  Injuries and trades using valuable chips (Doc for prospects; Marcum for Lawrie; etc.) have left the Jays short on quality ML pitching.  That, and a focus on improving other areas, have left the Jays with their rotation to address.  Whether Henderson Alvarez, Kyle Drabek, and Kyle Hutchison have developed as expected is a non-issue now.  Drabek and Hutch are out until next August at the earliest, halting their development and leaving holes in the rotation at the same time.  This brings us to the crux of the issue.  Alex Anthopoulos has filled a number of holes (OF defense; C; 1B; 2B; 3B; SS; the ‘pen; etc.) since he took over as GM, and he’s left the starting rotation until last.  Some of those holes have been filled admirably; some less so.  At the risk of sounding alarmist, the next problem may be replacing Jose Bautista at the same time as addressing the rotation.

Earlier this season, the Diamondbacks lost patience with their struggling star CF, Justin Upton.  Barely halfway into a season following one when he received strong MVP consideration, Upton was on the block.  Rumours spread and pretty soon, 23-year old Justin Upton was on everyone’s wish list.  I dreamed of an outfield patrolled by Jose Bautista, Colby Rasmus, and Justin Upton.  Is an off-season deal for a player like Upton reasonable?  Well, yielding prospects for a player like Justin Upton means those prospects aren’t available when a deal needs to be made for a pitcher or two.  What about free agency?  It’s less likely, with budget constraints and Alex Anthopoulos’s stated preference for using the farm and trade routes to build the team.  Given these realities, a player of the calibre of Justin Upton is less likely regardless of how enticing such a move would be.

Potentially, those are two issues that Toronto faces.  Jose Bautista is replaceable; the Jays have chosen not to replace him at this point.  Now they need to consider replacing him at the same time that they need to acquire starting pitchers to help this rebuilding squad move forward.  At this point, I’m going to take the Jays’ brass at their collective word and believe that: they want to build a winner, and the resources will be there when they’re needed.  That said, these two considerations–fortifying the rotation and finding another outfielder–have me drooling at the prospects in front of the Jays.

Wes Kepstro


3 Responses to “Drooling at the Prospects: Do the Jays Need to Replace Jose Bautista?”

  1. 1 Idiot Fan August 30, 2012 at 10:39 am

    Upton would be more of a luxury I think than a necessity. Also, while he could probably hold down CF, he is a full-time RF for Arizona.

    Cross your fingers and hope Joey Bats comes back man. He was the best hitter in the game last season and pretty damn solid this season outside of BABIP trouble.

    • 2 krazzykanuck August 30, 2012 at 11:37 am

      I hear you about the luxury/necessity distinction. This particular problem is two-headed (at least): Bautista’s out with the wrist injury, and they’re sub-par in LF, both offensively and defensively. I think Rajai’s a super 4th OF, given his native abilities, but long term he needs to be replaced.

      Additionally, prior to the Snider-for-Lincoln deal, the DBacks were rumoured to be interested in Snider. My thought was Joey Bats to LF, Rasmus in CF, and RF becomes Uptonland. As the advertisement says, “Imagine the possibilities”.

      Ultimately, though, Upton was only used hypothetically. Sort of a “good replacement for JB now/solid move long term” thing. There are several other names that could be inserted instead of “Justin Upton,” though. One of which is Moises Sierra. He’s already auditioning for the LF job.


      • 3 @ALEastbound August 30, 2012 at 8:51 pm

        I’ve always been a fan of Upton but this season has been a definite disappointment. I think he’d look great in a Jays uni though, at worst he gives great defense and solid speed. If he reaches his potential he is a top five overall talent.

Join the Discussion

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

AL Eastbound On Twitter!

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.